Tuesday, 22 March 2011

Knut: A polar bear story


Knut at Berlin zoo surrounded by a crowd
The death of Knut, the world's most famous polar bear, has reopened the debate on the ethical minefield of man's relationship with wild animals. So should polar bears be kept in zoos, asks Tom de Castella.
Knut was born in Berlin Zoo in December 2006. Rejected by his mother, he was put in an incubator and brought up by humans.
His abandonment, cute looks and close relationship with the charismatic zookeeper Thomas Doerflein, turned him into a huge star. He became an environmental symbol, acting as a mascot for the German government's campaign against climate change and being superimposed into a photograph with Leonardo DiCaprio for Vanity Fair's Green Issue in May 2007.
But news of his premature death at the weekend has spurred on those who question both the way Knut was treated and the very fact polar bears are in zoos at all.
While polar bears can live to 30 years old, Knut was only four years and three months when he died. A post-morterm examination suggested the cause of death was brain damage, but already there have been accusations from animal rights groups.

Knut's life

Knut as a cub
  • 2006: Born at Berlin zoo to 20-year-old mother Tosca
  • Rejected by mother and hand-reared by keeper Thomas Doerflein
  • March 2007: Debate about whether Knut should have been killed intensifies public affection
  • 2008: Doerflein dies of heart attack, aged 44
  • 2011: Knut dies
From the word go, Knut's life was controversial. Shortly after his birth, the German media reported that an animal rights campaigner was calling for him to be put down rather than brought up by humans. It prompted a huge groundswell of sympathy for the bear, which never went away.
For Andrew Linzey, director of the Oxford Centre for Animal Ethics, it is a tragic tale from start to finish.
"Frankly, it would have been better for Knut not to have existed at all than live such a miserable life."
Those who questioned the implications of Knut's hand-rearing have suggested he suffered inevitable behavioural problems as a result both of his treatment and the crowds at the zoo.
But Linzey, author of Why Animal Suffering Matters, believes the issue is not whether the zoo was right to hand rear Knut. Once the cub was born, the management had a duty to hand rear him because a zoo is an artificial, "controlled environment".
The fundamental problem is wild animals being kept in captivity at all, he argues. "Zoos impose unnatural lives on most of their captives. People just see a cuddly bear and they want to gawk at him, but what they should see is an animal deprived of its natural life, exhibited for entertainment and profit."

Polar bears in the wild

Polar bear and two cubs in Hudson Bay
  • Born deaf and blind beneath the snow
  • Adults spend most of their lives alone
  • Polar bears use keen sense of smell to track blubber-rich prey, and are strong swimmers
And profit became a big part of Knut's short life. In 2007 alone Berlin Zoo made an estimated five million euros through increased ticket and merchandising sales. Hundreds of fluffy white toys were sold every day across the city, newspapers offered Knut figurines for 148 Euros and in 2008 a movie, Knut and His Friends, opened in cinemas across Germany.
Knut's life was about celebrity rather than natural history, says Ian Redmond, a consultant to the Born Free Foundation's polar bear project in Canada.
"It does seem to highlight the dichotomy of people who love this one polar bear in particular and those who care about polar bears right across the species."
He sees little point in keeping large powerful animals in captivity. Not only do they lead "unfulfilled lives", but bears bred in zoos cannot be reintroduced to the wild as they lose the skills necessary to survive.
And those creatures bred in zoos become less and less like the wild animals we admire from natural history programmes, majestically leaping from ice floe to ice floe.
"As you breed in zoos down the generations you're getting further and further away from polar bear behaviour in the wild," argues Redmond. "You might be breeding out the traits that allow it to survive in the wild. What's the point? If you want cute cuddly bears for merchandising then that's a commodity."
In Knut's case critics suggested he had developed odd behavioural traits and had come to find the presence of the crowds necessary.
In recent years all but one British zoo has stopped keeping polar bears, a decision Redmond urges Berlin to follow.
Footage of Knut in March 2007, shortly before his first public appearance
But at the Highland Wildlife Park near Aviemore, Britain's only zoo to have polar bears, they are going in the opposite direction. The park has an elderly female and a young male, and when the former dies there are plans to bring in a young female so that mating can begin.
Douglas Richardson, the zoo's animal collection manager, says they have learnt lessons from the past. In the 1980s polar bears became "the poster child" for anti-zoo movement after being kept in cramped concrete pits whose only attempt at recreating the bear's eco-system was white paint.
"I came up with a design that gives the animals between five and six acres of fenced off rolling landscape in the middle of the Highlands."
Richardson said that that much of the criticism of Berlin Zoo - such as over their merchandising policy - was unjustified.
"The European Zoo community pumps the money it earns from merchandise back into conservation in the field. I guarantee that when we have cubs the giftshop here will be full of fluffy polar bear toys and that money will be going to conservation. You have to take advantage of the situation. The money is not going to line someone's pockets."
The wildlife broadcaster Chris Packham acknowledges that a polar bear in captivity loses the ability to relate to bears in the wild. And he believes that if wild polar bears die out there is no point keeping some alive in zoos.
But he argues that zoos have a crucial advocacy role for animals in the wild. And if a zoo is treating the bear well - as he believes Berlin Zoo was with Knut - then keeping some in captivity is a price worth paying.
Thomas Doerflein with Knut ... and missed his handler Thomas Doerflein
"We don't need many polar bears in captivity. But sacrificing those animals is justified as they become ambassadors for their species, striking awe into the hearts of humans. We don't want bears and tigers to go extinct."
The immediacy of zoo animals will always wow children and adults in a way that television documentaries cannot, he says.
"I can still remember aged 12 going to the zoo and seeing a tiger for the first time. I could barely speak I was so in awe of the animal."
That has benefits not just for raising awareness about wild polar bears but for dramatising the issue of climate change. Many people might find it hard to visualise abstract notions such as a two degree temperature rise in 50 years' time. But the polar bear losing the ice it relies on for hunting seals, is a story that we can all understand, he says.
"The long-term prognosis is tough for polar bears. So I'd argue that if Knut attracted a million people to see him and they were impressed by what they saw that is the most important role that a zoo can play."


20 comments:

Anonymous said...

Many people can be fighting payday loan arrears in the nation due to the bad financial state. Using conditions deteriorating everyday, there is all the more familys stricken by the possible lack of jobs. Quite a few need reevaluated cash advance loans, which will bill exceptionally increased low interest rates and cause some sort of pattern in non stop credit debt. There are numerous who wish to discover to take out an advance payday loan, nevertheless are unaware of that ways required to achieve this. You should understand how to remove an online payday loan quickly you need to complications because of especially cuts as a result of interest levels. This text can provide your step-by-step information to shed this payday advance credit debt.
Just how to shed a payday loan Accompanied by a
[url=http://szybkie-pozyczki.info.pl]pożyczki w 15 min[/url]

Step one you'll want to carry to try and force due to payday loan personal debt is definitely telephone a trained online payday loan consolidator as quickly as possible. These companies and also people today will have that skills wanted to make a deal in your stead to get a lower speed. Lots of payday cash advance providers recognise that some might never ever secure any kind of his or her cash back whether they are certainly not much more lenient on the subject of low interest rates. In most cases, the eye levels for the bank loan may be altogether cut despite the fact that primarily the principle bank loan is required to be repaid.
[url=http://pozyczka-pozabankowa.net.pl]pozyczki bez bik prywatne[/url]

Some people will need a number of payday cash advances to be able to completely different organizations, this really is a remarkably very important attribute because will certainly reduce the credit debt debt load considerably. More importantly, the particular payday advance consolidator should deal with any mortgage loan that allows you to start the particular loan consolidation for one's payment for.
Getting rid of an advance payday loan by means of Economizing
[url=http://szybkie-pozyczki.info.pl]kredyt pozabankowy bez bik[/url]

The next growth phase significant step up ridding yourself of payday cash advance consumer debt may be to implement numerous substantial introspective intellect searching regarding your own personal having to pay habits. Web site about logic behind why you should be in payday loans personal debt, nonetheless too much investing would probably be a large contribute to with regard to issue. For everybody who is going out to restaurants, irrespective of the way in which low priced, you are likely investing money. To be able to discover to eliminate a cash payday loan, you have to very first actually lower your costs.
[url=http://pozyczka-pozabankowa.net.pl]dowiedz się więcej[/url]

You can perform it by looking to any grocery that allows you to populate all of the cuisine necessities. Decide to buy primarily the requirements, including breads, ova, some fruits, plus home grown vegetables, and steer clear of another soda pops as well as foodstuffs that could be destructive on your resources. Utilizing discount coupons can be a different way of saving bucks used in an effort to pay the balance of your borrowing products much faster.
[url=http://kredyt-na-dowod.org.pl]kredyt na dowód[/url]

At last, make sure to structure released many of the pleasure that you choose to put money into through the entire four weeks. It could signify an individual give up alcohol consumption, evade movie theaters, as well as almost every other kind of satisfaction which is pricing people profit. It truly is the perfect time to make eschew to recieve ones cash advance loan personal debt cared for quickly.
[url=http://pozyczka-pozabankowa.net.pl]pożyczka pozabankowa[/url]

Anonymous said...

Chords introduce harmony into music and it is the effects created by chords that produce the inspiration behind so much music and
make it so satisfying both to listen to and to play.
Www. These hail every little thing played getting rid of barely the sophisticated
keys, so you ought to keep effective toward crush extra
listed below barely a limited area of time.

My site - free piano chords and keys

Anonymous said...

In other words, they go against the grain of the careers
their parents had. Popular prizes include sports tickets, cash and vouchers for drinks, food - and dollars off
of tabs. The decline of the East side blues scene was disheartening, but, it also
gave rise to the need for a fresh start, which came in the form of the next blues-only venue, Antone's, founded by the late Clifford Antone, during the summer of 1975.

my blog post: good pub quiz names

Anonymous said...

Hello! I'm at work browsing your blog from my new iphone! Just wanted to say I love reading your blog and look forward to all your posts! Keep up the fantastic work!

Visit my weblog ... password Cracker

Anonymous said...

On Sunday nights Erin Jaimes hosts a blues jam where anyone
from Alan Haynes to Gary Clark, Jr. *Rounds table format.
The food is decent and the drink specials on Tuesdays include $2.


Feel free to visit my weblog best pub quiz names

Anonymous said...

If your tween is into paint-ball you can take everyone to play paint-ball.
Unfortunately for me as an addict, I need
my crime fix. At each house you have the hostess serve something
small to eat, and host a small game.

My blog hawaii vacations

Anonymous said...

I like this post, enjoyed this one thank you for posting.

"'I have done my best.' That is about all the philosophy of living one needs." by Lin Yutang.


Feel free to surf to my site: $20 PSN Card

Anonymous said...

I could not refrain from commenting. Very well written!


My weblog How to Detect and Stop Aimbot Cheaters in Shooter Games

Anonymous said...

What You Can Gain. Anti Nutrients:. Ingredients.

Here is my blog: paleo diet and pregnancy

Anonymous said...

I think that what you published was actually very logical.
But, what about this? suppose you added a little information?
I am not suggesting your information is not good.

, however what if you added something that makes people want more?
I mean "Knut: A polar bear story" is a little vanilla. You might glance at Yahoo's front page and see how they create news headlines to grab people to open the links. You might try adding a video or a related picture or two to grab readers interested about what you've written.
Just my opinion, it would make your posts a little
bit more interesting.

my webpage - How To Earn Money While Unemployed

Anonymous said...

there are lots of family dog web pages which provide totally free information on several unique
instruction troubles. You should teach your dog and talk to him during training sessions.

Dog obedience training is a bit more than trained responses.


My web-site: electronic Dog training aids

Anonymous said...

Your style is very unique compared to other people I've read stuff from. Thanks for posting when you've got
the opportunity, Guess I will just bookmark this site.

Also visit my web blog :: Red Head Videos Free XXX Videos

Anonymous said...

Hey I know this is off topic but I was wondering if you knew of any
widgets I could add to my blog that automatically tweet my newest twitter updates.
I've been looking for a plug-in like this for quite some time and was hoping maybe you would have some experience with something like this. Please let me know if you run into anything. I truly enjoy reading your blog and I look forward to your new updates.

my homepage ... castleville tips

Anonymous said...

I love reading through an article that will make men and women think.
Also, thank you for allowing for me to comment!


My page; adfly Hack

Anonymous said...

The only hurdle to accessing this is of course human limitations
and the fact that the brain does not function solely as
a learning tool for the human being. *Rounds table format.
They feature almost nightly drink specials and some form
of entertainment every night of the week--DJ's, live music, trivia, you name it.

My site - pub quiz answers and questions

Anonymous said...

I'd like to find out more? I'd love to find out more details.



Also visit my web site ... castle ville quests

Anonymous said...

I conceive this website contains some very
superb info for everyone. "Glory is fleeting, but obscurity is forever." by Napoleon.


My blog post: $20 PSN Card

Anonymous said...

Upon returning to the starting line, the first player must pass the sugar cube to the next teammate in line and so
on. The game was released on August 3, and is in
stores now, but probably is where it will remain, sad to say.

Play games all night long in keeping with the twenties theme
such as various card games and crossword puzzles.

Also visit my blog atlanta refinance

Anonymous said...

The decor on the inside of the restaurant is absolutely beautiful.

Below are listed a few popular pubs where one can chill in Mumbai.

The buccal cavity is a small cavity that has neither jaws nor
teeth.

My web site :: fun pub quiz names

Anonymous said...

On Sunday nights Erin Jaimes hosts a blues jam where anyone from Alan Haynes
to Gary Clark, Jr. Anna had been looking through my phone while I was naked.

Theme Format: It is almost like standard format of the pub quiz.


Also visit my weblog ... pub quiz and answers

The Men Who Stole the World: Inside the 2008 Financial Crisis

A look at how top executives on Wall Street helped trigger a global financial crisis - and how it may happen again. 24 Jun 2019 14:16 ...